- Mike def. Luke Savage, Malik Mayfield, and J. J. Hefley in a Fatal 4-Way Match to become the inaugural champion
- Maui Mike was stripped of the title due to no-showing the May 23rd ASP event. Mayfield def. Drake Gallows to win the title in the King of the Livestream Tournament.
- Griffey def. Mayfield for the title in a match where Griffey’s ASP Heavyweight & 5-Star Titles were also on the line.
- Mayfield def. Griffey for the title in a Sinister 6 Gauntlet match that also involved Tino Valentino, Double D, Johnny Kove and Luke Richmond
- Gallows def. Mayfield in a Triple Threat Match that also involved Luke Savage
- The title was announced as vacant on December 31, 2021. Mayfield def. Maui Mike, Scott Sanders and Shawn Sanders in a Fatal 4-Way Match for the vacant title.
- Mike def. Mayfield in a Title-vs-Title match where his ASP Mid-American Title was also on the line
- Maui Mike vacated the title for reasons unknown sometime prior to the March 26th event. Wolf def. Skidz and Jason Simon in a Triple Match for the vacant title
- The Wolf of War was stripped of the title after failing to show up for a mandatory title defence. Mayfield def. Mitch Onyx for the vacant title
|